« Flight from reality | Main | Chaucer doth blog »

A clash between civilisations, not about civilisation

In his speech on foreign policy last night, Tony Blair memorably said: "This is not a clash between civilisations, it is a clash about civilisation." Then there was this anecdote: "Shortly after Saddam fell, I met in London a woman who after years of exile — and there were 4 million such exiles — had returned to Iraq to participate in modern politics there. A couple of months later, she was assassinated, one of the first to be so. I cannot tell what she would say now. But I do know it would not be: give up. She would not want her sacrifice for her beliefs to be in vain."

Commenting on the speech, Paul Reynolds, the BBC's World Affairs Correspondent says: "Mr Blair's critics will see all this as simply an attempt to justify the unjustifiable and the illegal — the invasion of Iraq." The issue that "Mr Blair's critics" need to address is this, though: If Saddam was illegally removed from power; he is entitled to be restored to power. But, oddly enough, I don't hear Paul Reynolds or the anti-war crowd making that argument.

But then, they don't have any arguments as convincing as this: "It is the age-old battle between progress and reaction, between those who embrace and see opportunity in the modern world and those who reject its existence; between optimism and hope on the one hand; and pessimism and fear on the other." Tony Blair.



TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.eamonn.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-t.cgi/1158

Comments

Eamonn,

Really excellent post - it was a challenge to do justice to Blair's #1 speech - you did better than my post. Linking to the full text transcript is another plus - readers need to know how to access the true speech, rather than the shrewdly-selected soundbites.

BTW, I found your blog via blogsearch.google.com [which I just discovered] - and I've added you to my daily-read tab.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Movable Type


Honoured member of the Rainy Day family