Hitchens on Hamas
In "Bad Timing", which is subtitled: "Gaza could have been a model of the future Palestinian state. Instead, it is a place of repression and aggression," Christopher Hitchens gives the Israelis and the Palestinians a ticking off before addressing the "disgusting and squalid behavior of the Hamas gang".
"It knows very well that sanctions are injuring every Palestinian citizen, but — just like Saddam Hussein's regime in Iraq — it declines to cease the indiscriminate violence and the racist and religious demagogy that led to the sanctions in the first place. Palestine is a common home for several religious and national groups, but Hamas dogmatically insists that the whole territory is instead an exclusively Muslim part of a future Islamic empire. At a time when democratic and reformist trends are observable in the region, from Lebanon to the Gulf, Hamas' leadership is physically and economically a part of the clientele of two of the area's worst dictatorships. (Should you ever be in need of a free laugh, look up those Western 'intellectuals' who believe that a vote for an Islamist party and an Islamic state is a way to vote against corruption! They have not lately studied Iran and Saudi Arabia.) Gaza could have been a prefiguration of a future self-determined Palestinian state. Instead, it has been hijacked by the Muslim Brotherhood and made into a place of repression for its inhabitants and aggression for its neighbors."
With a typical flourish, he signs off: "But to see Hamas at work is to resolve that whatever replaces or follows Zionism, it must not be the wasteland of Islamic theocracy." Agreed.
Comments
Been follwing your tweets on #gaza with interest, Eamonn.
I agree with your position that Hamas is evil and that it is guilty of murdering Israelies, including children. You are also correct that many people reflexively condemn Israel when it seeks to defend itself, forgetting it is surrounded by powers that more or less want it "wiped off the map".
BUT, while Israel is not attempting to murder children in the current operation, she is failing in her moral duty to care for civilians effectively penned into the Gaza Strip.
Or do you believe that Israel and Palestine should be treated as though they were two neighbouring countries with equivalent moral contexts?
Posted by: Fin Keegan | January 14, 2009 11:34 AM